COMMENT: M&S clings to Rose-tinted future
The news of a shareholder revolt against M&S CEO and chairman Stuart Rose at yesterday's AGM has garnered an extraordinary amount of press coverage here in the UK.
That it did reflects both the exalted position of corporate governance on the news agenda at the moment and the place of Marks and Spencer in the hearts and minds of the British public, media and business community.
A large minority of M&S shareholders - around 37% - backed an advisory motion at the AGM calling for the chain to appoint a new independent chairman a year earlier than planned, splitting the job that Rose currently carries out.
The move would bring M&S's board make-up in line with the current consensus on corporate governance best practice.
Opinion in the media and in the city seems against Rose today. The common argument is that whilst he holds both the position of CEO and chairman, too much power is concentrated in the M&S boss' hands.
Councillor Ian Greenwood, who sponsored the motion, told the BBC in a piece on their website today that he hoped that the board would "reflect seriously on this result."
"If you concentrate too much power in one place it unbalances the governance," he said.
Significantly different roles
Few seem to doubt Rose's ability to lead M&S through one of the most difficult periods in modern retail times from the position of CEO.
However, the jobs of chief executive and chairman are significantly different roles - one leads the company the other leads the board. They are also both huge jobs. Is it realistic to believe one man can carry out both at the same time effectively?
There is also the small matter of succession, but Sir Stuart's potential replacements are thin on the ground. He is due to stand down as chief executive in 2010 and from M&S in 2011.
The search for a successor should be in full swing but there are a number of investors in the business that believe Rose's dual role gives him too much say in who his likely successor will be.
This, opponents say will see him appoint his own man, in his own mould, rather than the best man for the job.
The heat was also recently turned up a notch with the news that deputy chairman Sir David Michels has designs on the chairmanship.
Despite the arguments against and the considerable opposition from institutional investors, Rose remained in bullish mood yesterday after the vote.
"It doesn't matter if it was 51% - 49% or 60% - 40%; a win is a win," he told the BBC, rather reminding one of a sports team manager defending the nature of his team's ugly win.
"I don't feel like a wounded beast - I feel like a chief executive and a chairman, because after all I am both, who wants to carry on and take our company through this recessionary period."
And it is not as if Rose is without legitimacy.
Rose, by his own addmission, recognises that the company is out of kilter with corporate governance code. "We just have a different view [to the opposing shareholders] as to how we get there," he said yesterday.
Rose's argument is that this is not the time to rock the boat.
The company is moving towards a separation of the CEO and chairman's roles but, in the midst of the economic crisis, it is a step that should not be rushed nor take precedence over the business of steering the company through extraordinary times.
The fact that obvious candidates to fill one of the roles are thin on the ground makes this argument all the more pertinent.
"I feel that this continued attacking is irrelevant to the point of being vindictive," said Sir Richard Greenbury, the former chief executive of Marks & Spencer said in the Telegraph yesterday.
"Stuart Rose has done an excellent job after six years of decline under three failed chief executives.
"This is the worst recession since the early 1990s and this is not the time to rock the boat and fiddle and piddle around about what someone's job title is," he said.
And as Greenbury pointed out, M&S has had four non-executive chairmen in five years. In such unstable times, the company would argue that it can ill-afford to add to the insecurity by changing the chairman again.
Furthermore the anecdotal and statistical evidence suggests that the vast majority of investors and employees believe in their man.
As just-style walked the floor at yesterday's AGM, our man on the ground found it hard to find a dissenting voice amongst the independent shareholders, who remain fiercely loyal to M&S and Rose.
The mood, indeed, was summed up beautifully, by the man who stood up to defend Rose against his detractors, telling the CEO to ignore the city institutions who were calling for him to step down from the chairmanship, whilst adding that they "couldn't run a bath".
By Chris Brook-Carter.
Help test our new apparel sourcing tool.
New York-based specialty athletic retailer Foot Locker Inc is to shutter 117 stores, cut 120 jobs and consolidate its businesses under one management team in a move designed to offset slowing sales in...
Pakistan's government has imposed ceiling of 50,000 tons per month on the export of cotton yarns from the country. The ceiling will be effective from 1st January 2010....
More than 170 jobs are at risk after Scottish Borders-based JJ&HB Cashmere Mills - better known under its former name Ballantyne Cashmere - went into administration....
Here is a roundup of the top five most-read stories on just-style this week. Click on each headline for the full story....
Department store retailer Sears Holdings has opened up its website to third-party sellers, including competitors, as part of a new online mall called Sears Marketplace....
The following is a general roundup of US apparel and shoe chains' December 2009 sales results. The list will be updated as new results become available....
Swedish fashion chain H&M is gearing up to launch a sustainable fashion line this spring made entirely from organic and recycled materials....
Women's wear retailer Christopher & Banks Corporation posted growth in underlying third quarter profit despite continuing revenue decline....
- Rana Plaza four years on – Timeline of change
- Why collaboration is key to fashion supply chains
- Industry groups reaffirm commitment to Bangladesh
- Trump and Brexit get a dose of pragmatism
- Using worker surveys to drive supply chain change
- Adidas to digitalise Speedfactory concept
- Nike filed patent for "reinforced denim"
- M&S extends sourcing deal with Lindsey brothers
- Gap unveils five-year sustainable fibres pledge
- US Q1 in brief – Columbia Sportswear, Amazon
- Global market review of denim and jeanswear – forecasts to 2022
- When Things Go Wrong - A Practical Guide to Managing Common Problems in Apparel Sourcing
- Clothing Market in the Top 5 American Countries to 2021 - Market Size, Development, and Forecasts
- Outdoor performance apparel 2016: A broader perspective
- Southeast Asia strategic sourcing review – a focus on Cambodia, Vietnam and Myanmar