Comment: Three cheers for a living wage!
The concept of a living wage is not new...but its implementation is
The concept of paying a living wage for garment workers in developing countries is not new - yet its implementation continues to present challenges across the apparel supply chain, as Michael Lavergne explains.
For many designers who have put countless years of study and sweat into their careers and into the design and manufacture of their own creations, the concept of a guaranteed "living wage" for apparel industry workers seems sure to raise a cheer.
Very few, if any, successful industry players would claim that the road to paying one's dues in the rag trade is paved with gold. Long hours, low pay and even less recognition early on are the norm.
Yet for tens of thousands of developing country garment workers, achieving a living wage may mean the difference between a life of poverty and one where workers can provide the hope of a better life for themselves and their children.
The concept of a living wage is not a new one. In fact, contained within the wording of Article 23 of the United Nations Universal Declaration on Human Rights are the explicit expectations of sufficient wages to guarantee workers everywhere "an existence worthy of human dignity".
This ideal has formed the basis on which NGOs, trade unions and civil society organisations have pushed the discussion of living wage guarantees from concept to concrete policy.
Social sustainability is one of the key tenants of the Triple Bottom Line, in which an organisation's success should take into account its financial, social and environmental performance: profit, people and planet.
Arguably, responsible business leaders who may genuinely want to ensure social accountability in their supply chains must balance those desires with the financial viability of their companies.
This has often led to various sectors of the industry decrying the logic of increased wages at the bottom of the supply chain pyramid.
Here we are addressing the vast majority of market supply and demand, low to mid-priced branded apparel sourced from low cost manufacturing countries primarily in South Asia and Central America, where everyone from the sewing operator to the store cashier depends on their cut of a garment's margin.
Fair wage pressures
Leading NGOs such as the UK-based Ethical Trading Initiative (ETI), which counts hundreds of brands and retailers as members, have long pushed the industry to go beyond its commitments to ensuring that suppliers pay at least minimum wages and benefits.
But in an industry where factory workers across most of the developing world earn less than an average of US$250 per month, major brands and retailers still spend a significant amount of time and effort dealing with issues of non-payment of wages, failure to provide required local benefits, and proper overtime pay.
The ETI and others such as the Fair Wear Foundation (FWF), the Fair Labor Association and the UN's International Labor Organization have all called for setting living wages which consider not only local minimum salaries but also food inflation, education expenses, health care, discretionary income and other cost of living concerns.
In doing so, the FWF has spent considerable time analysing the actual per garment cost impacts of increasing a production worker's wages. Its detailed Wage Labour background study published in 2011 looked at manufacturing, wholesale and retail pricing impacts across a number of low cost production countries - and projected manageable cost increases at retail of less than 5% on average when almost doubling existing 2010 pay rates against Asia Floor Wage recommendations.
A lack of agreement on formulas for calculating living wages has also been an excuse offered by some industry sources. As the ETI contends in its comments on the issue, it is more important "that companies don't allow the challenge of how to calculate a living wage to distract them from getting on with raising wages".
With the rise of sustainability initiatives among brands, and increased calls everywhere for more attention to the social aspects of corporate social responsibility, ensuring that up-and-coming design industry professionals fully understand the impacts of their manufacturing options early on will go a long way to supporting the Triple Bottom Line's success in the future.
Earning a fair wage in this industry is something every one of us can relate to on a very real and human level.
Michael Lavergne is a sustainable supply chain consultant with 20 years of multinational branded sourcing experience, having worked for Wal-Mart, Hanesbrands, WRAP and Bureau Veritas. He is currently based in Toronto, Canada.
UK supermarket brand George at Asda is on a journey to a more sustainable supply chain through its Responsible Retail programme. Lynne Tooms, senior director of quality and sourcing, explains why reta...
Project Synopsis: MarketLine's Company Mergers & Acquisitions (M&A), Partnerships & Alliances and Investments reports offer a comprehensive breakdown of the organic and inorganic growth activity unde...
Hanesbrands Inc. (HBI) - Financial and Strategic SWOT Analysis Review provides you an in-depth strategic SWOT analysis of the company’s businesses and operations. The profile has been compiled by Glob...
In 2008, the US-based multinational company Wal-Mart Stores acquired the Chilean hypermarket, supermarket and retail company D&S, which already owned more than 250 stores across the country. Every yea...
Strong international sales, fuelled by acquisitions, helped apparel group Hanesbrands to nearly treble third-quarter profit on a double-digit sales increase....
Wal-Mart de México SAB de CV is the leading and most influential chained grocery retailer in Mexico. The company’s strategy is based on offering a wide range of products at affordable prices. Conseque...
- Low labour cost countries linked to highest risks
- Why should brands care about China cotton?
- UK reshoring hub hit by sweatshop claims
- New fibre and fabric innovations for outdoor wear
- China cotton: implications and opportunities
- South Africa to grow grass for recyclable textiles
- US West Coast port contract reached
- 30% of Adidas cotton from sustainable sources
- Activewear driving US apparel spend
- Benetton to embark on living wage roadmap
- Outdoor performance apparel: peaks, valleys, and green fields
- Myanmar's Garment Sector - Opportunities & Challenges in 2015
- Global market review of swimwear - forecasts to 2019
- Management briefing: Outlook 2015: Apparel industry issues in the year ahead
- Apparel Retail: Top 5 Emerging Markets Industry Guide